A problem with golf coaching

Lisa is a friend of Clare’s (the way better half) and was staying with us over the weekend. Clare was showing Lisa some of my new golf training aids and Lisa, being a sporty type, was interested in having a go.

Lisa had never picked up a golf club before, a complete newbie, but already had some preconceived ideas about golf;

“I don’t know how to stand”
“I don’t know how to hold the club”
“Golf is really hard”
“I’m nervous. I don’t know what to do”.

Her comments took me a bit by surprise. She has played hockey for years and is a good athlete. But although interested in golf, she was apprehensive about it. She was scared of making any sort of mistake and doing something wrong. And this is a huge problem with learning. If you’re fearful of making mistakes then you really won’t get out of first gear – you’ll be tight, over controlling and won’t find golf fun.

Lisa posed a challenge I’m up for. I’m convinced that traditional golf coaching has gotten out of hand, and there’s easier and better ways of making a difference. Below is a rundown of an impromptu golf lesson I gave Lisa in the lounge room. Just so you know, I used some Almost Golf Balls and we kept things to a basic chip shot. Here’s the lesson.

Me: Lisa, we’re going to hit some chip shots. These are a small shot that get airborne for a short distance and then run towards the flag. (I demonstrated by throwing a ball underhanded towards the coffee table).

Lisa: How do I stand? I don’t know how to stand…

Me: It doesn’t really matter how you stand. Stand in a way that’s comfortable.

Lisa: But how do I hold the club? Isn’t there some special grip I need to use?

Me: No, your grip is not that important just yet. Hold the club in anyway that feels good to you and allows you to swing back and forwards with enough power to hit the ball a short distance.

Lisa: Ok. (She made a few practice swings without a ball)

Me: Good. You’re doing find. There’s nothing too it. Just swing back and forth.

Lisa: But my grip is wrong!

Me: No it’s not. There’s no right and wrong. We’re just learning here and having some fun.

Lisa: Ok. But tell me if I’m doing anything wrong…

Me: Righto Lisa, I’m going to push you a little harder now. To help golfers learn to improve their chipping more quickly I’ve designed the ChipMaster Pro. It’s a simple device that teaches you to hit the ball cleanly. Many golfers don’t understand they need to strike the ball first. (I demonstrated the difference between a clean strike and a “fat” shot).

Lisa: Ok. That looks easy enough.

Me: So your objective here is to chip the ball off the mat. If you hit the ball “fat” you’ll strike the lip. If you get the ball thin your club won’t hit the mat in front of the ball (the ChipMaster Pro has a red “impact area” in front of the ball which is a guide where the bottom of the club should strike the ground”). Why don’t you give it a go?

Lisa: But I don’t know how to swing!

Me: It doesn’t matter right now. There’s no right and wrong. We’re just having some fun and learning. Mistakes are good anyway, they speed up the learning process.

Lisa relaxed a little and stepped up to the shot. She hit the ball fat…

Me: How did that feel?

Lisa: I hit the lip thing and the ball didn’t go anywhere.

Me: Correct. That’s what happened. You’ve got good awareness on what’s happening. Why don’t you have another go…

Lisa tried a few more times and got a mixture of fat and thinned shots. This was not overly surprising because she has never played before – many long term golfers do the same on a regular basis.

Me: Lisa, one of the key things with chipping is to strike the ball first. And to make this easier to do you can place the ball further back in your stance, in your case this is off of your right foot. When you chip from this position it becomes a million times easier to make clean contact with the ball.

Lisa: But what about my grip?

Me: Lisa, it really doesn’t matter. Stop worrying about your grip and stance, we’ll cover that later.

I moved the ChipMaster Pro so the ball was positioned off of her back foot. Her hands went forward (naturally) and she made another attempt. This time she made good contact. The ball sailed off of her club, hit my knee and went into the side wall. There were some power issues but she had made a good shot.

Lisa: That one felt nice. Sorry about hitting you in the knee.

Me: Good work Lisa and don’t worry about the knee. Remember, there’s no right and wrong here, we’re just having some fun. Let’s try again.

We went back and forwards, hitting some shots and chatting away. After a few minutes, Lisa really started to get it. She wasn’t hitting perfectly, but was getting enough good shots to keep her interested. After a thinned shot she said, “Arrgghh. I thinned that one. I didn’t strike the ground in front of the ball”.

Me: Correct. Can you show me a different version please?

Lisa made some practice swings and brushed the ground in front of the ball.

Me: Great work. Now let’s hit a ball.

Lisa hit three nice shots in a row. She had reduced the power and the balls flew a few metres and bumped into the coffee table. She was learning how to chip and it wasn’t taking too long.

Lisa: But is my stance ok? I’m really worried about my stance.

Me: Can you stand on one leg? I want you to make some chips standing on your right leg

This wasn’t even a challenge for her. Because she new the basic concept of chipping (hit the ball first and then the ground) it wasn’t too hard for her. She made two perfect shots in a row standing on one leg.

Me: See? Your stance isn’t important. As long as you can strike the ball first, it doesn’t really matter about your stance. There’s no right and wrong.

Lisa: Yes. I see. It really is simple. I thought golf was going to be really difficult.

Me: It can be. I teach a little differently than most. I don’t bombard you with lots of rules – just enough for you to achieve the objective. I let you learning system do the hard yards and work out the finer detail itself. In time, when you play more, your technique will change. But this will happen gradually and naturally – there’s no point in trying to do this all at once.

Lisa: Thanks, this is fun.

We finished off with Lisa hitting chip shots off one leg and with one hand. By now she wasn’t worried about her stance or swing and was focused on hitting the ball. The smile on her face as she hit another perfect shot told me that we’d both done well.

Golf coaching needs to be made simple. It’s a worry that novices are scared of the game – and fearful of doing something wrong. The focus really needs to be on hitting the ball and allowing the subconscious to do the heavy lifting. Too much technique and information hinders development and can’t be much fun. Coaching isn’t about how much advice the coach can impart onto the student (this is a traditional mindset) but rather how little. If coaches were forced to halve the amount of words spoken improvement would skyrocket – enjoyment would increase and more would play the game.

Comment using Facebook

9 Comments

  • Grayden Provis

    Reply Reply December 3, 2012

    So many good things going on here. The really radical thing is that you allow the student to do it “wrong”. Thats the big departure IMO.

    • Cameron

      Reply Reply December 4, 2012

      GP: Yep. When the student relaxes and realises there are NO Mistakes they open up. Learning/improvement/success/fun become the byproduct. When they also relaise they don’t have to have perfect technique and they’re free to add their own style, things can happen really quickly.

  • James Smith

    Reply Reply December 4, 2012

    I need to get one of those ChipMasters and use it to help some of my golf buddies who are just starting out! 🙂

    • Cameron

      Reply Reply December 4, 2012

      James: it works great with beginners 🙂 Lisa was laughing the next day saying she was almost an expert.

  • Cam280

    Reply Reply December 4, 2012

    Took a week off, from the game. Played almost a round today: conditions 38 degrees (hot) & blowing 15 knots (windy) walked. Analysis fell into some old bad habits i.e mechanics, and scoring. I want to talk about scoring. Once I let go of the notion that scoring meant something and trusted my instincts and sub conscious my game came back to me with ease. Most of the text say, ignore your score, its not easy to do. Any thoughts on the subject?.

    • Cameron

      Reply Reply December 4, 2012

      Cam280: Sometimes we can be too hard on ourselves. And sometimes it’s just good to play for the love of the game. Who cares about your score anyway? Most of the time it’s just you – others are too worried about their own game too worry about you. Yes, it’s not easy, people ask,

      how did you go?
      what score did you have?
      how did you play?

      Not many ask,

      what did you learn?
      what was your experience like?
      what did you feel?
      did you have fun?

      This blog has 100’s of articles and snippets of advice to help. It’s also a journey. It might take years to fully appreciate what’s happening here. Again, many many golfers are too worried about their score, swing and results to notice.

      My advice is to get outside and go play by yourself. Find a quiet time when you’re not going to be bothered – and play your way. Hit the shots you want to hit and then report back.

  • Cam280

    Reply Reply December 4, 2012

    I want to get my handicap down to scratch, Most of the time when I play comp i’m stuck with higher handicap golfers, I get no feeling of competition or inspiration to play my best. I see many golfers that have a lower handicap than myself that rarely when I play them that they beat me. It’s complicated, I know I am better than my handicap suggests, I did reach a personal best this year with an 8.8 anchor but now drifted back to 9.4. I played roughly 90 competitive rounds so far this year, I have dropped from 12 at the start of the year to 9. I started playing golf 12 years ago, but this year is my first year that I have been able to put so much time into it. So many subtle changes I have made to my approach to the game but would you say I am being impatient?. The only other thing I can think thats stagnating my progress is the C.C.R at my course is 5 under par. It seems to add stress knowing I have to shoot 5 under my handicap to play to it, but then I think I should be able to achieve it if I am going to be a scratch golfer.

    • Cameron

      Reply Reply December 4, 2012

      Cam280: Your handicap is a stupid number. I know it means a lot to many golfers but it’s only a representation of your golfing skill – it’s not you or your golf game. So my best advice is to forget about it. Keep playing in a way that’s meaningful to you, your handicap will take care of itself.

      More to come.

  • Cam280

    Reply Reply December 4, 2012

    The truth of the matter is; Golf gives me hope that I can make my millions, with out having to rely on the market place, but competitions are the market place for golfers. So I have to compete against golfers with higher handicaps. But when golfers reach 3 or less they have the opportunity to play against each other on an even playing field regarding handicap. Surely thats when the real competition of golf starts. So how do I get to scratch?

Leave A Response

* Denotes Required Field